Monday, August 20, 2012

LAW/POL-TED Talks-Michael Sandel: The lost art of democratic debate

The following information is used for educational purposes only.


Transcript:



One thing the world needs,one thing this country desperately needsis a better wayof conducting our political debates.We need to rediscoverthe lost art of democratic argument.(Applause)If you think about the arguments we have,most of the time it's shouting matcheson cable television,ideological food fights on the floor of Congress.I have a suggestion.Look at all the arguments we have these daysover health care,over bonuses and bailouts on Wall Street,over the gap between rich and poor,over affirmative action and same-sex marriage.Lying just beneath the surfaceof those arguments,with passions raging on all sides,are big questionsof moral philosophy,big questions of justice.But we too rarelyarticulate and defendand argue aboutthose big moral questions in our politics.

So what I would like to do todayis have something of a discussion.First, let me takea famous philosopherwho wrote about those questionsof justice and morality,give you a very short lectureon Aristotle of ancient Athens,Aristotle's theory of justice,and then have a discussion hereto see whether Aristotle's ideasactually informthe way we think and argueabout questions today.So, are you ready for the lecture?According to Aristotle,justice means giving people what they deserve.That's it; that's the lecture.

(Laughter)

Now, you may say, well, that's obvious enough.The real questions beginwhen it comes to arguing aboutwho deserves what and why.Take the example of flutes.Suppose we're distributing flutes.Who should get the best ones?Let's see what people --What would you say?Who should get the best flute?You can just call it out.

(Audience: Random.)

Michael Sandel: At random. You would do it by lottery.Or by the first person to rush into the hall to get them.Who else?

(Audience: The best flute players.)

MS: The best flute players. (Audience: The worst flute players.)

MS: The worst flute players.How many say the best flute players?Why?Actually, that was Aristotle's answer too.

(Laughter)

But here's a harder question.Why do you think,those of you who voted this way,that the best flutes should go to the best flute players?

Peter: The greatest benefit to all.

MS: The greatest benefit to all.We'll hear better musicif the best flutes should go to the best flute players.That's Peter? (Audience: Peter.)

MS: All right.Well, it's a good reason.We'll all be better off if good music is playedrather than terrible music.But Peter,Aristotle doesn't agree with you that that's the reason.That's all right.Aristotle had a different reasonfor saying the best flutes should go to the best flute players.He said,that's what flutes are for --to be played well.He says that to reason aboutjust distribution of a thing,we have to reason about,and sometimes argue about,the purpose of the thing,or the social activity --in this case, musical performance.And the point, the essential nature,of musical performanceis to produce excellent music.It'll be a happy byproductthat we'll all benefit.But when we think about justice,Aristotle says,what we really need to think aboutis the essential nature of the activity in questionand the qualities that are worthhonoring and admiring and recognizing.One of the reasonsthat the best flute players should get the best flutesis that musical performanceis not only to make the rest of us happy,but to honorand recognizethe excellenceof the best musicians.

Now, flutes may seem ... the distribution of flutesmay seem a trivial case.Let's take a contemporary exampleof the dispute about justice.It had to do with golf.Casey Martin -- a few years ago,Casey Martin --did any of you hear about him?He was a very good golfer,but he had a disability.He had a bad leg, a circulatory problem,that made it very painfulfor him to walk the course.In fact, it carried risk of injury.He asked the PGA,the Professional Golfers' Association,for permission to use a golf cartin the PGA tournaments.They said, "No.Now that would give you an unfair advantage."He sued,and his case went all the wayto the Supreme Court, believe it or not,the case over the golf cart,because the law saysthat the disabledmust be accommodated,provided the accommodation does notchange the essential natureof the activity.He says, "I'm a great golfer.I want to compete.But I need a golf cartto get from one hole to the next."

Suppose you wereon the Supreme Court.Suppose you were decidingthe justice of this case.How many here would saythat Casey Martin does have a right to use a golf cart?And how many say, no, he doesn't?All right, let's take a poll, show of hands.How many would rule in favor of Casey Martin?And how many would not? How many would say he doesn't?All right, we have a good division of opinion here.Someone who would notgrant Casey Martin the right to a golf cart,what would be your reason?Raise your hand, and we'll try to get you a microphone.What would be your reason?

(Audience: It'd be an unfair advantage.)

MS: It would be an unfair advantageif he gets to ride in a golf cart.All right, those of you,I imagine most of you who would not give him the golf cartworry about an unfair advantage.What about those of you who sayhe should be given a golf cart?How would you answer the objection?Yes, all right.

Audience: The cart's not part of the game.

MS: What's your name? (Audience: Charlie.)

MS: Charlie says --We'll get Charlie a microphone in case someone wants to reply.Tell us, Charlie,why would you say he should be able to use a golf cart?

Charlie: The cart's not part of the game.

MS: But what about walking from hole to hole?

Charlie: It doesn't matter; it's not part of the game.

MS: Walking the course is not part of the game of golf?

Charlie: Not in my book, it isn't.

MS: All right. Stay there, Charlie.

(Laughter)

Who has an answer for Charlie?All right, who has an answer for Charlie?What would you say?

Audience: The endurance element is a very important part of the game,walking all those holes.

MS: Walking all those holes?That's part of the game of golf? (Audience: Absolutely.)

MS: What's your name? (Audience: Warren.)

MS: Warren.Charlie, what do you say to Warren?

Charley: I'll stick to my original thesis.

(Laughter)

MS: Warren, are you a golfer?

Warren: I am not a golfer.

Charley: And I am. (MS: Okay.)(Laughter)

(Applause)

You know,it's interesting.In the case, in the lower court,they brought in golfing greatsto testify on this very issue.Is walking the course essential to the game?And they brought in Jack Nicklaus and Arnold Palmer.And what do you suppose they all said?Yes. They agreed with Warren.They said, yes, walking the courseis strenuous physical exercise.The fatigue factor is an important part of golf.And so it would changethe fundamental nature of the gameto give him the golf cart.Now, notice,something interesting --Well, I should tell you about the Supreme Court first.

The Supreme Courtdecided.What do you suppose they said?They said yes,that Casey Martin must be provided a golf cart.Seven to two, they ruled.What was interesting about their rulingand about the discussion we've just hadis that the discussion aboutthe right, the justice, of the matterdepended onfiguring out what isthe essential nature of golf.And the Supreme Court justiceswrestled with that question.And Justice Stevens, writing for the majority,said he had read all about the history of golf,and the essential point of the gameis to get very small ball from one placeinto a holein as few strokes as possible,and that walking was not essential, but incidental.

Now, there were two dissenters,one of whom was Justice Scalia.He wouldn't have granted the cart,and he had a very interesting dissent.It's interesting becausehe rejected the Aristotelian premiseunderlying the majority's opinion.He said it's not possibleto determine the essential natureof a game like golf.Here's how he put it."To say that something is essentialis ordinarily to say that it is necessaryto the achievement of a certain object.But since it is the very nature of a gameto have no object except amusement,(Laughter)that is, what distinguishes gamesfrom productive activity,(Laughter)it is quite impossible to saythat any of a game's arbitrary rulesis essential."

So there you have Justice Scaliataking on the Aristotelian premiseof the majority's opinion.Justice Scalia's opinionis questionablefor two reasons.First, no real sports fan would talk that way.(Laughter)If we had thought that the rulesof the sports we care aboutare merely arbitrary,rather than designed to call forththe virtues and the excellencesthat we think are worthy of admiring,we wouldn't care about the outcome of the game.It's also objectionableon a second ground.On the face of it,it seemed to be -- this debate about the golf cart --an argument about fairness,what's an unfair advantage.But if fairness were the only thing at stake,there would have been an easy and obvious solution.What would it be? (Audience: Let everyone use the cart.)Let everyone ride in a golf cartif they want to.Then the fairness objection goes away.

But letting everyone ride in a cartwould have been, I suspect,more anathemato the golfing greatsand to the PGA,even than making an exception for Casey Martin.Why?Because what was at stakein the dispute over the golf cartwas not only the essential nature of golf,but, relatedly, the question:What abilitiesare worthyof honor and recognitionas athletic talents?Let me put the pointas delicately as possible:Golfers are a little sensitiveabout the athletic status of their game.(Laughter)After all, there's no running or jumping,and the ball stands still.(Laughter)So if golfing is the kind of gamethat can be played while riding around in a golf cart,it would be hard to conferon the golfing greatsthe status that we confer,the honor and recognitionthat goes to truly great athletes.That illustratesthat with golf,as with flutes,it's hard to decide the questionof what justice requires,without grappling with the question,"What is the essential natureof the activity in question,and what qualities,what excellencesconnected with that activity,are worthy of honor and recognition?"

Let's take a final examplethat's prominent in contemporary political debate:same-sex marriage.There are those who favor state recognitiononly of traditional marriagebetween one man and one woman,and there are those who favor state recognitionof same-sex marriage.How many herefavor the first policy:the state should recognize traditional marriage only?And how many favor the second, same-sex marriage?Now, put it this way:What ways of thinkingabout justice and moralityunderlie the arguments we haveover marriage?The opponents of same-sex marriage saythat the purpose of marriage,fundamentally, is procreation,and that's what's worthy of honoringand recognizing and encouraging.And the defenders of same-sex marriage say no,procreation is not the only purpose of marriage;what about a lifelong, mutual, loving commitment?That's really what marriage is about.So with flutes, with golf carts,and even with a fiercely contested questionlike same-sex marriage,Aristotle has a point.Very hard to argue about justicewithout first arguingabout the purpose of social institutionsand about what qualities are worthyof honor and recognition.

So let's step back from these casesand see how they shed lighton the way we might improve, elevate,the terms of political discoursein the United States,and for that matter, around the world.There is a tendency to thinkthat if we engage too directlywith moral questions in politics,that's a recipe for disagreement,and for that matter, a recipe forintolerance and coercion.So better to shy away from,to ignore,the moral and the religious convictionsthat people bring to civic life.It seems to me that our discussionreflects the opposite,that a better wayto mutual respectis to engage directlywith the moral convictionscitizens bring to public life,rather than to requirethat people leave their deepest moral convictionsoutside politicsbefore they enter.That, it seems to me, is a wayto begin to restorethe art of democratic argument.

Thank you very much.

(Applause)

Thank you.

(Applause)

Thank you.

(Applause)

Thank you very much.Thanks. Thank you.Chris.Thanks, Chris.

Chris Anderson: From flutes to golf coursesto same-sex marriage --that was a genius link.Now look, you're a pioneer of open education.Your lecture series was one of the first to do it big.What's your vision for the next phase of this?

MS: Well, I think that it is possible.In the classroom, we have argumentson some of the most fiercely heldmoral convictions that students haveabout big public questions.And I think we can do that in public life more generally.And so my real dream would beto take the public television seriesthat we've created of the course --it's available now, online,free for everyone anywhere in the world --and to see whether we can partner with institutions,at universities in China, in India,in Africa, around the world,to try to promotecivic educationand also a richer kindof democratic debate.

CA: So you picture, at some point,live, in real time,you could have this kind of conversation, inviting questions,but with people from China and India joining in?

MS: Right. We did a little bit of it herewith 1,500 people in Long Beach,and we do it in a classroom at Harvardwith about 1,000 students.Wouldn't it be interestingto take this wayof thinking and arguing,engaging seriously with big moral questions,exploring cultural differencesand connect through a live video hookup,students in Beijing and Mumbaiand in Cambridge, Massachusettsand create a global classroom.That's what I would love to do.

(Applause)

CA: So, I would imaginethat there are a lot of people who would love to join you in that endeavor.Michael Sandel. Thank you so much. (MS: Thanks so much.)



LAW/INTAFF/POL-TED Talks-Auret van Heerden: Making global labor fair

The following information is used for educational purposes only.



Transcript:

This cell phonestarted its trajectoryin an artisanal minein the Eastern Congo.It's mined by armed gangsusing slaves, child slaves,what the U.N. Security Councilcalls "blood minerals,"then traveled into some componentsand ended up in a factoryin Shinjin in China.That factory -- over a dozen people have committed suicidealready this year.One man died after working a 36-hour shift.We all love chocolate.We buy it for our kids.Eighty percent of the cocoa comes from Cote d'Ivoire and Ghanaand it's harvested by children.Cote d'Ivoire, we have a huge problem of child slaves.Children have been trafficked from other conflict zonesto come and work on the coffee plantations.Heparin -- a blood thinner,a pharmaceutical product --starts out in artisanal workshopslike this in China,because the active ingredientcomes from pigs' intestines.Your diamond -- you've all heard, probably seen the movie "Blood Diamond."This is a mine in Zimbabweright now.Cotton: Uzbekistan is the second biggestexporter of cotton on Earth.Every year when it comes to the cotton harvest,the government shuts down the schools,puts the kids in buses, buses them to the cotton fieldsto spend three weeks harvesting the cotton.It's forced child laboron an institutional scale.And all of those products probably end their livesin a dump like this one in Manila.

These places, these origins,represent governance gaps.That's the politest descriptionI have for them.These are the dark poolswhere global supply chains begin --the global supply chains,which bring us our favorite brand name products.Some of these governance gapsare run by rogue states.Some of them are not states anymore at all.They're failed states.Some of themare just countries who believe that deregulation or no regulationis the best way to attract investment,promote trade.Either way, they present uswith a huge moral and ethical dilemma.I know that none of us want to be accessoriesafter the factof a human rights abusein a global supply chain.But right now,most of the companies involved in these supply chainsdon't have any wayof assuring usthat nobody had to mortgage their future,nobody had to sacrifice their rightsto bring us our favoritebrand name product.

Now, I didn't come here to depress youabout the state of the global supply chain.We need a reality check.We need to recognize just how seriousa deficit of rights we have.This is an independent republic,probably a failed state.It's definitely not a democratic state.And right now,that independent republic of the supply chainis not being governedin a way that would satisfy us,that we can engage in ethical trade or ethical consumption.Now, that's not a new story.You've seen the documentariesof sweatshops making garmentsall over the world, even in developed countries.You want to see the classic sweatshop,meet me at Madison Square Garden,I'll take you down the street, and I'll show you a Chinese sweatshop.

But take the example of heparin.It's a pharmaceutical product.You expect that the supply chain that gets it to the hospital,probably squeaky clean.The problem is that the active ingredient in there --as I mentioned earlier --comes from pigs.The main American manufacturerof that active ingredientdecided a few years ago to relocate to Chinabecause it's the world's biggest supplier of pigs.And their factory in China --which probably is pretty clean --is getting all of the ingredientsfrom backyard abattoirs,where families slaughter pigsand extract the ingredient.So a couple of years ago, we had a scandalwhich killed about 80 people around the world,because of contaminantsthat crept into the heparin supply chain.Worse, some of the suppliersrealized that they could substitute a productwhich mimicked heparin in tests.This substitute cost nine dollars a pound,whereas real heparin, the real ingredient,cost 900 dollars a pound.A no-brainer.The problem was that it killed more people.

And so you're asking yourself,"How come the U.S. Food and Drug Administrationallowed this to happen?How did the Chinese State Agency for Food and Drugsallow this to happen?"And the answer is quite simple:the Chinese define these facilitiesas chemical facilities, not pharmaceutical facilities,so they don't audit them.And the USFDAhas a jurisdictional problem.This is offshore.They actually do conduct a few investigations overseas --about a dozen a year -- maybe 20 in a good year.There are 500of these facilitiesproducing active ingredients in China alone.In fact, about 80 percentof the active ingredients in medicines nowcome from offshore,particularly China and India,and we don't have a governance system.We don't have a regulatory systemable to ensurethat that production is safe.We don't have a system to ensurethat human rights, basic dignity,are ensured.

So at a national level --and we work in about 60 different countries --at a national levelwe've got a serious breakdown in the ability of governmentsto regulate productionon their own soil.And the real problem with the global supply chainis that it's supranational.So governments who are failing,who are dropping the ballat a national level,have even less ability to get their arms around the problemat an international level.And you can just look at the headlines.Take Copenhagen last year --complete failure of governmentsto do the right thingin the face of an international challenge.Take the G20 meeting a couple of weeks ago --stepped back from its commitments of just a few months ago.You can take any oneof the major global challenges we've discussed this weekand ask yourself, where is the leadership from governmentsto step up and come up with solutions,responses,to those international problems?And the simple answer is they can't. They're national.Their voters are local.They have parochial interests.They can't subordinate those intereststo the greater global public good.

So, if we're going to ensure the deliveryof the key public goodsat an international level --in this case, in the global supply chain --we have to come up with a different mechanism.We need a different machine.Fortunately, we have some examples.In the 1990s,there were a whole series of scandalsconcerning the production of brand name goods in the U.S. --child labor, forced labor,serious health and safety abuses.And eventually President Clinton, in 1996,convened a meeting at the White House,invited industry, human rights NGOs,trade unions, the Department of Labor,got them all in a roomand said, "Look,I don't want globalization to be a race to the bottom.I don't know how to prevent that,but I'm at least going to use my good officesto get you folks togetherto come up with a response."So they formed a White House task force,and they spent about three years arguingabout who takes how much responsibilityin the global supply chain.Companies didn't feel it was their responsibility.They don't own those facilities.They don't employ those workers.They're not legally liable.Everybody else at the tablesaid, "Folks, that doesn't cut it.You have a custodial duty, a duty of care,to make sure that that productgets from wherever to the storein a way that allows us to consume it,without fear of our safety,or without having to sacrifice our conscienceto consume that product."So they agreed, "Okay, what we'll dois we agree on a common set of standards,code of conduct.We'll apply that throughoutour global supply chainregardless of ownership or control.We'll make it part of the contract."And that was a stroke of absolute genius,because what they didwas they harnessed the power of the contract,private power,to deliver public goods.

And let's face it,the contract from a major multinational brandto a supplier in India or Chinahas much more persuasive valuethan the local labor law,the local environmental regulations,the local human rights standards.Those factories will probably never see an inspector.If the inspector did come along,it would be amazing if they were ableto resist the bribe.Even if they did their jobs,and they cited those facilities for their violations,the fine would be derisory.But you lose that contractfor a major brand name,that's the differencebetween staying in business or going bankrupt.That makes a difference.So what we've been able to dois we've been able to harnessthe power and the influenceof the only truly transnational institutionin the global supply chain,that of the multinational company,and get them to do the right thing,get them to use that power for good,to deliver the key public goods.

Now of course, this doesn't come naturallyto multinational companies.They weren't set up to do this. They're set up to make money.But they are extremely efficient organizations.They have resources,and if we can add the will, the commitment,they know how to deliver that product.Now, getting there is not easy.Those supply chains I put up on the screen earlier,they're not there.You need a safe space.You need a place where people can come together,sit down without fear of judgment,without recrimination,to actually face the problem,agree on the problem and come up with solutions.We can do it. The technical solutions are there.The problem is the lack of trust, the lack of confidence,the lack of partnershipbetween NGOs, campaign groups,civil society organizationsand multinational companies.If we can put those two together in a safe space,get them to work together,we can deliver public goods right now,or in extremely short supply.

This is a radical proposition,and it's crazy to thinkthat if you're a 15-year-old Bangladeshi girlleaving your rural villageto go and work in a factory in Dhaka --22, 23, 24 dollars a month --your best chance of enjoying rights at workis if that factory is producingfor a brand name companywhich has got a code of conductand made that code of conduct part of the contract.It's crazy.Multinationals are protecting human rights.I know there's going to be disbelief.You'll say, "How can we trust them?"Well, we don't.It's the old arms control phrase:"Trust, but verify."So we audit.We take their supply chain, we take all the factory names,we do a random sample,we send inspectors on an unannounced basisto inspect those facilities,and then we publish the results.Transparency is absolutely critical to this.You can call yourself responsible,but responsibility without accountabilityoften doesn't work.So what we're doing is, we're not only enlisting the multinationals,we're giving them the tools to deliver this public good --respect for human rights --and we're checking.You don't need to believe me. You shouldn't believe me.Go to the website. Look at the audit results.Ask yourself, is this company behavingin a socially responsible way?Can I buy that productwithout compromising my ethics?That's the way the system works.

I hate the ideathat governments are not protecting human rights around the world.I hate the ideathat governments have dropped this balland I can't get used to the ideathat somehow we can't get them to do their jobs.I've been at this for 30 years,and in that time I've seenthe ability, the commitment, the will of governmentto do this decline,and I don't see them making a comeback right now.So we started out thinkingthis was a stopgap measure.We're now thinking that, in fact,this is probably the startof a new way of regulating and addressinginternational challenges.Call it network governance. Call it what you will.The private actors,companies and NGOs,are going to have to get togetherto face the major challenges we are going to face.Just look at pandemics --swine flu, bird flu, H1N1.Look at the health systems in so many countries.Do they have the resourcesto face up to a serious pandemic?No.Could the private sector and NGOsget together and marshal a response?Absolutely.What they lack is that safe spaceto come together, agreeand move to action.That's what we're trying to provide.

I know as wellthat this often seemslike an overwhelming level of responsibilityfor people to assume."You want me to deliver human rightsthroughout my global supply chain.There are thousands of suppliers in there."It seems too daunting, too dangerous,for any company to take on.But there are companies.We have 4,000 companies who are members.Some of them are very, very large companies.The sporting goods industry, in particular,stepped up to the plate and have done it.The example, the role model, is there.And whenever we discussone of these problems that we have to address --child labor in cottonseed farms in India --this year we will monitor 50,000 cottonseed farms in India.It seems overwhelming.The numbers just make you want to zone out.But we break it down to some basic realities.

And human rightscomes down to a very simple proposition:can I give this person their dignity back?Poor people,people whose human rights have been violated --the crux of thatis the loss of dignity,the lack of dignity.It starts with just giving people back their dignity.I was sitting in a slum outside Gurgaonjust next to Delhi,one of the flashiest, brightest new citiespopping up in India right now,and I was talking to workerswho worked in garment sweatshops down the road,and I asked them what message they would like me to take to the brands.They didn't say money.They said, "The people who employ ustreat us like we are less than human,like we don't exist.Please ask them to treat us like human beings."That's my simple understanding of human rights.That's my simple proposition to you,my simple plea to every decision-makerin this room, everybody out there.We can all make a decisionto come togetherand pick up the balls and run with the ballsthat governments have dropped.If we don't do it,we're abandoning hope,we're abandoning our essential humanity,and I know that's not a place we want to be,and we don't have to be there.So I appeal to you.Join us, come into that safe space,and let's start to make this happen.

Thank you very much.

(Applause)



LAW-TED Talks-Drew Curtis: How I beat a patent troll

The following information is used for educational purposes only.



Transcript:
Last January, my company, Fark.com, was suedalong with Yahoo, MSN, Reddit,AOL, TechCrunch and othersby a company called Gooseberry Natural Resources.Gooseberry owned a patentfor the creation and distributionof news releases via email.(Laughter)Now it may seem kind of strange that such a thing can actually be patented,but it does happen all the time.

Take something already being doneand patent it for an emerging technology --like phone calls on the internetor video listings for TV showsor radio but for cellphones,and so on.The problem with these patentsis that the mechanisms are obscureand the patent system is dysfunctional,and as a result, most of these lawsuits end in settlements.And because these settlements are under a non-disclosure agreement,no one knows what the terms were.And as a result, the patent troll can claimthat they won the case.

In the case of Gooseberry Natural Resources,this patent on emailing news releaseshad sort of a fatal flawas it pertained to myself,and that was that in the mainstream media worldthere is only one definition for news release,and it turns out that is press release --as in P.R.Now my company, Fark,deals with news, ostensibly,and as a resultwe were not in violation of this patent.So case closed, right?Wrong.

One of the major problems with patent law is that,in the case that when you are sued by a patent troll,the burden of proof that you did not infringe on the patentis actually on the defendant,which means you have to provethat you do not infringe on the patent they're suing you on.And this can take quite a while.You need to know that the average patent troll defensecosts two million dollarsand takes 18 months when you win.That is your best case outcomewhen you get sued by a patent troll.

Now I had hoped to team up with some of these larger companiesin order to defend against this lawsuit,but one-by-one they settled out of the case,even though -- and this is important --none of these companiesinfringed on this patent -- not a one of them.And they started settling out.The reason they settled outis because it's cheaper to settle than to fight the lawsuit --clearly, two million dollars cheaper in some cases,and much worse if you actually lose.It would also constitute a massive distraction for management of a company,especially a small eight-man shop like my company.

Six months into the lawsuit,we finally reached the discovery phase.And in discovery phase,we asked the patent troll to please providescreenshots of Farkwhere the infringement of their patentwas actually occurring.Now perhaps it's because no such screenshots actually existed,but suddenly Gooseberry wanted to settle.Their attorney:"Ah, yes. My company's having a reorganization on our end."Never mind the factthat the address led to a strip mall somewhere in Northern L.A.with no employees."And we'd like to go ahead and close this out.So would you mind giving us your best and final offer?"My response:"How about nothing?!"(Applause)We didn't have high hopes for that outcome.(Laughter)But they settled.No counter offer.

Now, as mentioned before,one of the reasons I can talk to you about thisis because there's no non-disclosure agreement on this case.Now how did that happen?Well during the settlement process, when we received our copy, I struck it.My attorney said, "Nah, no chance of that working."It came back signed.Now why? You can call them.They're not under NDA either.

Now what did I learn from this case? Well, three things.First of all, if you can,don't fight the patent, fight the infringement.Patents are very difficult to overturn.Infringement is a lot easier to disprove.Secondly, make it clear from the beginningthat either you have no money at allor that you would rather spend money with your attorney fighting the trollthan actually giving them the money.Now the reason this worksis because patent trollsare paid a percentage of what they're able to recover in settlements.If it becomes clear to them that they cannot recover any money,they become less interested in pursuing the case.

Finally, make sure that you can tell themthat you will make this processas annoying and as painfuland as difficult as possible for them.Now this is a tactic that patent trolls are supposed to use on peopleto get their way.It turns out, because they're paid on contingency,it works really, really well in reverse.Don't forget that.

So what does all this mean?Well to sum up,it boils down to one thing:Don't negotiate with terrorists.(Applause)Patent trolls have done more damage to the United States economythan any domestic or foreignterrorist organization in historyevery year.And what do they do with that money?They plow it right back into filing more troll lawsuits.

Now this is the point in the Talkwhere I'm supposed to come up with some kind of a solution for the patent system.And the problem with thatis that there are two very large industry groupsthat have different outcomes in mindfor the patent system.The health care industrywould like stronger protections for inventors.The hi-tech industrywould like stronger protections for producers.And these goals aren't necessarily diametrically opposed, but they are at odds.And as a result, patent trolls can kind of live in the space in between.

So unfortunately I'm not smart enoughto have a solution for the patent troll problem.However, I did have this idea,and it was kind of good.And I thought, "I should patent this."(Laughter)Behold, patent infringement via mobile device --defined as a computer which is not stationary.My solution: award me this patentand I will troll them out of existence.

Thank you.

(Applause)




LAW-TED Talks-Margaret Gould Stewart: How YouTube thinks about copyright

The following information is used for educational purposes only.


Transcript:

So, if you're in the audience today,or maybe you're watching this talk in some other time or place,you are a participant in the digital rights ecosystem.Whether you're an artist, a technologist,a lawyer or a fan,the handling of copyright directly impacts your life.Rights management is no longersimply a question of ownership,it's a complex web of relationshipsand a critical part of our cultural landscape.YouTube cares deeply about the rights of content owners,but in order to give them choices about what they can dowith copies, mashups and more,we need to first identifywhen copyrighted material is uploaded to our site.

Let's look at a specific video so you can see how it works.Two years ago, recording artist Chris Brownreleased the official video of his single "Forever."A fan saw it on TV,recorded it with her camera phone,and uploaded it to YouTube.Because Sony Music had registered Chris Brown's videoin our Content ID system,within seconds of attempting to upload the video,the copy was detected,giving Sony the choice of what to do next.

But how do we know that the user's video was a copy?Well, it starts with content ownersdelivering assets into our database,along with a usage policythat tells us what to do when we find a match.We compare each uploadagainst all of the reference files in our database.This heat map is going to show youhow the brain of the system works.Here we can see the original reference filebeing compared to the user generated content.The system compares every momentof one to the other to see if there's a match.This means that we can identify a matcheven if the copy used is just a portion of the original file,plays it in slow motionand has degraded audio and video quality.And we do this every timethat a video is uploaded to YouTube.And that's over 20 hours of video every minute.When we find a match,we apply the policy that the rights owner has set down.

And the scale and the speed of this systemis truly breathtaking.We're not just talking about a few videos,we're talking about over100 years of video every day,between new uploads and the legacy scanswe regularly do across all of the content on the site.When we compare those hundred years of video,we're comparing it against millionsof reference files in our database.It would be like 36,000 peoplestaring at 36,000 monitorseach and every day, without so much as a coffee break.

Now, what do we do when we find a match?Well, most rights owners, instead of blocking,will allow the copy to be published.And then they benefit through the exposure,advertising and linked sales.Remember Chris Brown's video "Forever"?Well, it had its day in the sun and then it dropped off the charts,and that looked like the end of the story,but sometime last year, a young couple got married.This is their wedding video.You may have seen it.

(Music)

What's amazing about this is,if the processional of the wedding was this much fun,can you imagine how much fun the reception must have been?I mean, who are these people?I totally want to go to that wedding.

So their little wedding video went onto get over 40 million views.And instead of Sony blocking,they allowed the upload to occur.And they put advertising against itand linked from it to iTunes.And the song, 18 months old,went back to number four on the iTunes charts.So Sony is generating revenue from both of these.And Jill and Kevin, the happy couple,they came back from their honeymoonand found that their video had gone crazy viral.And they've ended up on a bunch of talk shows,and they've used it as an opportunity to make a difference.The video's inspired over 26,000 dollars in donationsto end domestic violence.The "JK Wedding [Entrance] Dance" became so popularthat NBC parodied it on the season finale of "The Office,"which just goes to show,it's truly an ecosystem of culture.Because it's not just amateurs borrowing from big studios,but sometimes big studios borrowing back.

By empowering choice, we can create a culture of opportunity.And all it took to change things aroundwas to allow for choice through rights identification.So why has no one ever solved this problem before?It's because it's a big problem,and it's complicated and messy.It's not uncommon for a single videoto have multiple rights owners.There's musical labels.There's multiple music publishers.And each of these can vary by country.There's lots of caseswhere we have more than one work mashed together.So we have to manage many claimsto the same video.

YouTube's Content ID system addresses all of these cases.But the system only works throughthe participation of rights owners.If you have content that others are uploading to YouTube,you should register in the Content ID system,and then you'll have the choiceabout how your content is used.And think carefully about the policies that you attach to that content.By simply blocking all reuse,you'll miss out on new art forms,new audiences,new distribution channelsand new revenue streams.

But it's not just about dollars and impressions.Just look at all the joythat was spread through progressive rights managementand new technology.And I think we can all agree that joy is definitely an idea worth spreading.

Thank you.(Applause)

LAW-TED Talks-Alan Siegel: Let´s simplify legal jargon!

The following information is used for educational purposes only.



Transcript:

So, basically we have public leaders,public officials who are out of control;they are writing bills that are unintelligible,and out of these bills are going to comemaybe 40,000 pages of regulations, total complexity,which has a dramatically negative impact on our life.If you're a veteran coming back from Iraq or Vietnamyou face a blizzard of paperwork to get your benefits;if you're trying to get a small business loan,you face a blizzard of paperwork.

What are we going to do about it? I define simplicityas a means to achieving clarity,transparency and empathy,building humanity into communications.I've been simplifying things for 30 years.I come out of the advertising and design business.My focus is understanding you people,and how you interact with the governmentto get your benefits,how you interact with corporations to decide whom you're going to do business with,and how you view brands.

So, very quickly, when President Obama said,"I don't see why we can'thave a one-page, plain English consumer credit agreement."So, I locked myself in a room,figured out the content,organized the document, and wrote it in plain English.I've had this checked by the two topconsumer credit lawyers in the country.This is a real thing.Now, I went one step further and said,"Why do we have to stick with the stodgy lawyersand just have a paper document? Let's go online."

And many peoplemight need help in computation.Working with the Harvard Business School,you'll see this example when you talk about minimum payment:If you spent 62 dollars for a meal,the longer you take to pay out that loan,you see, over a period of time using the minimum paymentit's 99 dollars and 17 cents.How about that? Do you think your bank is going to show that to people?But it's going to work. It's more effectivethan just computational aids.And what about terms like"over the limit"?Perhaps a stealth thing.Define it in context. Tell people what it means.

When you put it in plain English,you almost force the institutionto give the people a way, a default out of that,and not put themselves at risk.Plain English is aboutchanging the content.And one of the things I'm most proud ofis this agreement for IBM.It's a grid, it's a calendar.At such and such a date, IBM has responsibilities,you have responsibilities.Received very favorably by business.

And there is some good news to report today.Each year, one in 10 taxpayersreceives a notice from the IRS.There are 200 million letters that go out.Running through this typical letter that they had,I ran it through my simplicity lab,it's pretty unintelligible.All the parts of the document in red are not intelligible.We looked at doing over 1,000 letters that cover70 percent of their transactions in plain English.They have been tested in the laboratory.When I run it through my lab,this heat-mapping shows everythingis intelligible.And the IRS has introduced the program.

(Applause)

There are a couple of things going on right nowthat I want to bring to your attention.There is a lot of discussion nowabout a consumer financial protection agency,how to mandate simplicity.We see all this complexity.It's incumbent upon us,and this organization, I believe,to make clarity, transparencyand empathy a national priority.There is no way that we should allow governmentto communicate the way they communicate.There is no way we should do businesswith companies that have agreementswith stealth provisions and that are unintelligible.

So, how are we going to change the world?Make clarity, transparency and simplicity a national priority.I thank you.

(Applause)

POL/INTAFF/LAW-TED Talks-Misha Glenny investigates global crime networks

The following information is used for educational purposes only.


Transcript:

These are grim economic times,fellow TEDsters, grim economic times indeed.And so, I would like to cheer you upwith one of the great, albeit largely unknown,commercial success storiesof the past 20 years.Comparable, in its own very peculiar way,to the achievements of Microsoft or Google.And it's an industry which has bucked the current recessionwith equanimity.I refer to organized crime.

Now organized crime has been aroundfor a very long time, I hear you say,and these would be wise words, indeed.But in the last two decades,it has experienced an unprecedented expansion,now accounting for roughly 15 percentof the world's GDP.I like to call it the Global Shadow Economy,or McMafia, for short.

So what triggered this extraordinary growthin cross-border crime?Well, of course, there is globalization,technology, communications, all that stuff,which we'll talk about a little bit later.But first, I would like to take you backto this event:the collapse of communism.All across Eastern Europe, a most momentous episodein our post-war history.

Now it's time for full disclosure.This event meant a great deal to me personally.I had started smuggling books across the Iron Curtainto Democratic opposition groups in Eastern Europe,like Solidarity in Poland,when I was in my teens.I then started writing about Eastern Europe,and eventually I became the BBC's chief correspondent for the region,which is what I was doing in 1989.And so when 425 million peoplefinally won the rightto choose their own governments,I was ecstatic,but I was also a touch worriedabout some of the nastier thingslurking behind the wall.

It wasn't long, for example,before ethnic nationalismreared its bloody headin Yugoslavia.And amongst the chaos,amidst the euphoria,it took me a little while to understandthat some of the people who had wielded powerbefore 1989, in Eastern Europe,continued to do so after the revolutions there.Obviously there were characters like this.But there were also some more unexpected peoplewho played a critical role in what was going on in Eastern Europe.

Like this character. Remember these guys?They used to win the gold medals in weightliftingand wrestling, every four years in the Olympics,and they were the great celebrities of communism,with a fabulous lifestyle to go with it.They used to get great apartments in the center of town,casual sex on tap,and they could travel to the West very freely,which was a great luxury at the time.It may come as a surprise, but they played a critical rolein the emergence of the market economyin Eastern Europe.Or as I like to call them, they arethe midwives of capitalism.Here are some of those same weightliftersafter their 1989 makeover.

Now in Bulgaria --this photograph was taken in Bulgaria --when communism collapsed all over Eastern Europe,it wasn't just communism;it was the state that collapsed as well.That means your police force wasn't working.The court system wasn't functioning properly.So what was a business man in the brave new worldof East European capitalism going to doto make sure that his contracts would be honored?Well, he would turn to people who were called, rather prosaicallyby sociologists, privatized law enforcement agencies.We prefer to know them as the mafia.And in Bulgaria, the mafia was soon joinedwith 14,000 peoplewho were sacked from their jobs in the security servicesbetween 1989 and 1991.

Now, when your state is collapsing,your economy is heading south at a rate of knots,the last people you want coming on to the labor marketare 14,000 men and women whose chief skillsare surveillance,are smuggling, building underground networksand killing people.But that's what happened all over Eastern Europe.Now, when I was working in the 1990s,I spent most of the time coveringthe appalling conflict in Yugoslavia.

And I couldn't help noticethat the people who were perpetrating the appalling atrocities,the paramilitary organizations,were actually the same people runningthe organized criminal syndicates.And I came to think that behind the violencelay a sinister criminal enterprise.And so I resolved to travel around the worldexamining this global criminal underworldby talking to policemen,by talking to victims, by talking to consumersof illicit goods and services.But above all else, by talking to the gangsters themselves.

And the Balkans was a fabulous place to start.Why? Well of coursethere was the issue of law and order collapsing,but also, as they say in the retail trade,it's location, location, location.And what I noticed at the beginning of my researchthat the Balkans had turned into a vast transit zonefor illicit goods and services coming from all over the world.Heroin, cocaine,women being trafficked into prostitutionand precious minerals.

And where were they heading?The European Union, which by nowwas beginning to reap the benefits of globalization,transforming it intothe most affluent consumer market in history,eventually comprising some 500 million people.And a significant minorityof those 500 million peoplelike to spend some of their leisure time and spare cashsleeping with prostitutes,sticking 50 Euro notes up their noseand employing illegal migrant laborers.

Now, organized crime in a globalizing worldoperates in the same way as any other business.It has zones of production,like Afghanistan and Columbia.It has zones of distribution,like Mexico and the Balkans.And then, of course, it has zones of consumption,like the European Union, Japanand of course, the United States.The zones of production and distributiontend to lie in the developing world,and they are often threatened by appalling violenceand bloodshed.

Take Mexico, for example.Six thousand people killed there in the last 18 monthsas a direct consequence of the cocaine trade.But what about the Democratic Republic of Congo?Since 1998, five million people have died there.It's not a conflict you read about much in the newspapers,but it's the biggest conflict on this planetsince the Second World War.And why is it? Because mafias from all around the worldcooperate with local paramilitariesin order to seize the suppliesof the rich mineral resourcesof the region.

In the year 2000, 80 percent of the world's coltanwas sourced to the killing fieldsof the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo.Now, coltan you will find in almost every mobile phone,in almost every laptopand games console.The Congolese war lords were selling this stuff to the mafiain exchange for weapons,and the mafia would then sell it on to Western markets.And it is this Western desireto consumethat is the primary driverof international organized crime.

Now, let me show you some of my friends in action,caught conveniently on film by the Italian police,and smuggling duty-not-paid cigarettes.Now, cigarettes out the factory gate are very cheap.The European Union then imposes the highest taxes on them in the world.So if you can smuggle them into the E.U.,there are very handsome profits to be made,and I want to show you this to demonstratethe type of resources available to these groups.

This boat is worth one million Euros when it's new.And it's the fastest thing on European waters.From 1994, for seven years,20 of these boatsmade the trip across the Adriatic,from Montenegro to Italy, every single night.And as a consequence of this trade,Britain alone lost eight billion dollars in revenue.And instead that money went to underwrite the wars in Yugoslaviaand line the pockets of unscrupulous individuals.

Now Italian police, when this trade started,had just two boats which could go at the same speed.And this is very important, because the only way you can catch these guysis if they run out of gas.Sometimes the gangsters would bring with themwomen being trafficked into prostitution,and if the police intervened, they would hurlthe women into the seaso that the police had to go and save them from drowning,rather than chasing the bad guys.

So I have shown you this to demonstratehow many boats, how many vessels it takesto catch one of these guys.And the answer is six vessels.And remember, 20 of these speed boatswere coming across the Adriaticevery single night.So what were these guys doing with all the money they were making?

Well, this is where we come to globalization,because that was not just the deregulation of global trade.It was the liberalization of international financial markets.And boy, did that make it easyfor the money launderers.The last two decades have been the champagne erafor dirty lucre.

In the 1990s, we saw financial centers around the worldcompeting for their business,and there was simply no effective mechanismto prevent money laundering.And a lot of licit banks were also happyto accept depositsfrom very dubious sourceswithout questions being asked.

But at the heart of this, is the offshore banking network.Now these thingsare an essential part of the money laundering parade,and if you want to do something about illegal tax evasionand transnational organized crime, money laundering,you have to get rid of them.On a positive note, we at last have someone in the White Housewho has consistently spoken outagainst these corrosive entities.

And if anyone is concerned about what I believeis the necessity fornew legislation, regulation, effective regulation,I say, let's take a look at Bernie Madoff,who is now going to be spending the rest of his life in jail.Bernie Madoff stole 65 billion dollars.That puts him up there on the Olympus of gangsterswith the Colombian cartelsand the major Russian crime syndicates,but he did this for decadesin the very heart of Wall Street,and no regulator picked up on it.So how many other Madoffs are there on Wall Streetor in the city of London,fleecing ordinary folkand money laundering?Well I can tell you, it's quite a few of them.

Let me go on to the 101 of international organized crime now.And that is narcotics. Our second marijuana farm photograph for the morning.This one, however, is in central British Columbiawhere I photographed it.It's one of the tens of thousandsof mom-and-pop grow-ops in B.C.which ensure that over five percentof the province's GDP is accounted for by this trade.

Now, I was taken by inspector Brian Cantera,of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police,to a cavernous warehouse east of Vancouverto see some of the goods which are regularly confiscatedby the RCMPfrom the smugglers who are sending it,of course, down south to the United Stateswhere there is an insatiable marketfor B.C. Bud, as it's called,in part because it's marketed as organic,which of course goes down very well in California.(Laughter)(Applause)

Now, even by the police's admission,this makes not a dent in the profits, really,of the major exporters.Since the beginning of globalization,the global narcotics market has expanded enormously.There has, however, been no concomitant increasein the resources availableto police forces.

This, however, may all be about to change,because something very strange is going on.The United Nations recognizedearlier this -- it was last month actually --that Canada has become a key area of distribution and productionof ecstasy and other synthetic drugs.

Interestingly, the market shareof heroin and cocaine is going down,because the pills are getting ever better at reproducing their highs.Now that is a game changer,because it shifts production away from the developing worldand into the Western world.When that happens, it is a trendwhich is set to overwhelm our policing capacity in the West.The drugs policy which we've had in place for 40 yearsis long overdue for a very serious rethink,in my opinion.

Now, the recession.Well, organized crime has already adaptedvery well to the recession.Not surprising, the most opportunistic industryin the whole world.And it has no rules to its regulatory system.Except, of course, it has two business risks:arrest by law enforcement,which is, frankly, the least of their worries,and competition from other groups,i.e. a bullet in the back of the head.

What they've done is they've shifted their operations.People don't smoke as much dope, or visit prostitutes quite so frequentlyduring a recession.And so instead, they have invaded financialand corporate crime in a big way,but above all, two sectors,and that is counterfeit goodsand cybercrime.And it's been terribly successful.I would like to introduce you to Mr. Pringle.Or perhaps I should say, more accurately, Señor Pringle.

I was introduced to this bit of kit by a Brazilian cybercriminal.We sat in a car on the Avenue Paulistain São Paulo, together.Hooked it up to my laptop,and within about five minutes he had penetratedthe computer security systemof a major Brazilian bank.It's really not that difficult.And it's actually much easier becausethe fascinating thing about cybercrimeis that it's not so much the technology.

The key to cybercrime is what we call social engineering.Or to use the technical term for it,there's one born every minute.You would not believe how easy it isto persuade people to do things with their computerswhich are objectively not in their interest.And it was very soonwhen the cybercriminals learned that the quickest way to do this,of course, the quickest way to a person's walletis through the promise of sex and love.

I expect some of you remember the ILOVEYOU virus,one of the very great worldwide viruses that came.I was very fortunate when the ILOVEYOU virus came out,because the first person I received it fromwas an ex-girlfriend of mine.Now, she harbored all sorts of sentiments and emotions towards me at the time,but love was not amongst them.(Laughter)And so as soon as I saw this drop into my inbox,I dispatched it hastily to the recycle binand spared myself a very nasty infection.

So, cybercrime, do watch out for it.One thing that we do know that the Internet is doingis the Internet is assisting these guys.These are mosquitoes who carry the malarial parasitewhich infests our blood when the mosy has had a free mealat our expense.

Now, Artesunate is a very effective drugat destroying the parasite in the early daysof infection.But over the past year or so,researchers in Cambodia have discoveredthat what's happening isthe malarial parasite is developing a resistance.And they fear that the reason why it's developing a resistanceis because Cambodians can't afford the drugs on the commercial market,and so they buy it from the Internet.And these pills contain only low dosesof the active ingredient.Which is whythe parasite is beginning to develop a resistance.

The reason I say thisis because we have to knowthat organized crimeimpacts all sorts of areas of our lives.You don't have to sleep with prostitutesor take drugsin order to have a relationship with organized crime.They affect our bank accounts.They affect our communications, our pension funds.They even affect the food that we eatand our governments.

This is no longer an issueof Sicilians from Palermo and New York.There is no romance involved with gangstersin the 21st Century.This is a mighty industry,and it creates instability and violencewherever it goes.It is a major economic forceand we need to take it very, very seriously.It's been a privilege talking to you.Thank you very much.(Applause)




LAW/FASH-TED Talks-Johanna Blakley.Lessons from fashion´s free culture

The following information is used for educational purposes only.



Transcript:
I heard this amazing story about Miuccia Prada.She's an Italian fashion designer.She goes to this vintage store in Pariswith a friend of hers.She's rooting around, she finds this one jacket by Balenciaga --she loves it.She's turning it inside out.She's looking at the seams. She's looking at the construction.Her friend says, "Buy it already."She said, "I'll buy it, but I'm also going to replicate it."Now, the academics in this audience may think,"Well, that sounds like plagiarism."But to a fashionista, what it really isis a sign of Prada's genius:that she can root through the history of fashionand pick the one jacketthat doesn't need to be changed by one iota,and to be current and to be now.

You might also be asking whether it's possiblethat this is illegal for her to do this.Well, it turns out that it's actually not illegal.In the fashion industry, there's very littleintellectual property protection.They have trademark protection,but no copyright protectionand no patent protection to speak of.All they have, really, is trademark protection,and so it means that anybodycould copy any garmenton any person in this roomand sell it as their own design.The only thing that they can't copyis the actual trademark labelwithin that piece of apparel.That's one reason that you see logossplattered all over these products.It's because it's a lot harder for knock-off artiststo knock off these designsbecause they can't knock off the logo.But if you go to Santee Alley, yeah.(Laughter) Well, yeah.Canal Street, I know.And sometimes these are fun, right?

Now, the reason for this, the reason that the fashion industrydoesn't have any copyright protectionis because the courts decided long agothat apparel is too utilitarianto qualify for copyright protection.They didn't want a handful of designersowning the seminal building blocks of our clothing.And then everybody else would have to license this cuff or this sleevebecause Joe Blow owns it.But too utilitarian? I mean is that the way you think of fashion?This is Vivienne Westwood. No!We think of it as maybe too silly,too unnecessary.

Now, those of you who are familiar with the logicbehind copyright protection --which is that without ownership, there is no incentive to innovate --might be really surprisedby both the critical success of the fashion industryand the economic success of this industry.What I'm going to argue today is thatbecause there's no copyright protectionin the fashion industry,fashion designers have actually been able to elevateutilitarian design,things to cover our naked bodies,into something that we consider art.Because there's no copyright protectionin this industry,there's a very open and creativeecology of creativity.

Unlike their creative brothers and sisters,who are sculptors or photographersor filmmakers or musicians,fashion designers can samplefrom all their peers' designs.They can take any element from any garmentfrom the history of fashionand incorporate it into their own design.They're also notorious for riffing off of the zeitgeist.And here, I suspect,they were influenced by the costumes in Avatar.Maybe just a little.Can't copyright a costume either.

Now, fashion designers havethe broadest palette imaginablein this creative industry.This wedding dress hereis actually made of sporks,and this dress is actually made of aluminum.I've heard this dress actually sort of sounds like wind chimesas they walk through.So, one of the magical side effectsof having a culture of copying,which is really what it is,is the establishment of trends.People think this is a magical thing. How does it happen?Well, it's because it's legal for people to copy one another.

Some people believe thatthere are a few people at the top of the fashion food chainwho sort of dictate to us what we're all going to wear,but if you talk to any designer at any level,including these high-end designers,they always saytheir main inspiration comes from the street:where people like you and me remix and matchour own fashion looks.And that's where they really get a lot of theircreative inspiration,so it's both a top-down and a bottom-up kind of industry.

Now, the fast fashion giants haveprobably benefited the mostfrom the lack of copyright protection in the fashion industry.They are notorious for knocking off high-end designsand selling them at very low prices.And they've been faced with a lot of lawsuits,but those lawsuits are usually not won by fashion designers.The courts have said over and over again, "You don't needany more intellectual property protection."When you look at copies like this,you wonder: How do the luxury high-end brandsremain in business?If you can get it for 200 bucks, why pay a thousand?Well, that's one reason we had a conference here at USC a few years ago.We invited Tom Ford to come --the conference was called, "Ready to Share:Fashion and the Ownership of Creativity" --and we asked him exactly this question.Here's what he had to say.He had just come off a successful stint as the lead designer at Gucci,in case you didn't know.

Tom Ford: And we found after much researchthat -- actually not much research, quite simple research --that the counterfeit customer was not our customer.

Johanna Blakley: Imagine that.The people on Santee Alleyare not the ones who shop at Gucci.(Laughter)This is a very different demographic.And, you know, a knock-off is never the sameas an original high-end design,at least in terms of the materials; they're always made of cheaper materials.But even sometimes a cheaper versioncan actually have some charming aspects,can breathe a little extra life into a dying trend.There's lots of virtues of copying.One that a lot of cultural critics have pointed tois that we now havea much broader paletteof design choices to choose from than we ever have before,and this is mainly because of the fast fashion industry, actually.And this is a good thing. We need lots of options.

Fashion, whether you like it or not,helps you project who you are to the world.Because of fast fashion,global trends actually get established much more quickly than they used to.And this, actually, is good news to trendsetters;they want trends to be setso that they can move product.For fashionistas,they want to stay ahead of the curve.They don't want to be wearing what everybody else is wearing.And so, they want to move on to the next trendas soon as possible.

I tell you, there is no rest for the fashionable.Every season, these designers have to struggleto come up with the new fabulous idea that everybody's going to love.And this, let me tell you,is very good for the bottom line.Now of course, there's a bunch of effectsthat this culture of copying hason the creative process.And Stuart Weitzman is a very successful shoe designer.He has complained a lot about people copying him,but in one interview I read,he said it has really forced him to up his game.He had to come up with new ideas,new things that would be hard to copy.He came up with this Bowden-wedge heelthat has to be made out of steel or titanium;if you make it from some sort of cheaper material,it'll actually crack in two.It forced him to be a little more innovative. (Music)

And that actually reminded meof jazz great, Charlie Parker.I don't know if you've heard this anecdote, but I have.He said that one of the reasons he invented bebopwas that he was pretty surethat white musicians wouldn't be able to replicate the sound. (Laughter)He wanted to make it too difficult to copy,and that's what fashion designers are doing all the time.They're trying to put togethera signature look, an aestheticthat reflects who they are.When people knock it off, everybody knowsbecause they've put that look out on the runway,and it's a coherent aesthetic.

I love these Gallianos.Okay, we'll move on. (Laughter)

This is not unlike the world of comedy.I don't know if you know that jokesalso can't be copyright protected.So when one-liners were really popular,everybody stole them from one another.But now, we have a different kind of comic.They develop a persona,a signature style, much like fashion designers.And their jokes,much like the fashion designs by a fashion designer,really only work within that aesthetic.If somebody steals a jokefrom Larry David, for instance,it's not as funny.

Now, the other thing that fashion designers have doneto survive in this culture of copyingis they've learned how to copy themselves.They knock themselves off.They make deals with the fast fashion giantsand they come up with a way to sell their productto a whole new demographic:the Santee Alley demographic.

Now, some fashion designers will say,"It's only in the United States that we don't have any respect.In other countries there is protectionfor our artful designs."But if you take a look at the two other biggest markets in the world,it turns out that the protection that's offeredis really ineffectual.In Japan, for instance, which I think is the third largest market,they have a design law; it protects apparel,but the novelty standard is so high,you have to prove that your garment has never existed before,it's totally unique.And that's sort of likethe novelty standard for a U.S. patent,which fashion designers never get --rarely get here in the states.

In the European Union, they went in the other direction.Very low novelty standard,anybody can register anything.But even though it's the home of the fast fashion industryand you have a lot of luxury designers there,they don't register their garments, generally,and there's not a lot of litigation.It turns out it's because the novelty standard is too low.A person can come in and take somebody else's gown,cut off three inches from the bottom,go to the E.U. and register it as a new, original design.So, that does not stop the knock-off artists.If you look at the registry, actually,a lot of the registered things in the E.U.are Nike T-shirtsthat are almost identical to one another.

But this has not stopped Diane von Furstenberg.She is the head ofthe Council of Fashion Designers of America,and she has told her constituency thatshe is going to get copyright protectionfor fashion designs.The retailers have kind of quashed this notion though.I don't think the legislation is going anywhere,because they realized it is so hardto tell the difference between a pirated designand something that's just part of a global trend.Who owns a look?That is a very difficult question to answer.It takes lots of lawyers and lots of court time,and the retailers decided that would be way too expensive.

You know, it's not just the fashion industrythat doesn't have copyright protection.There's a bunch of other industries that don't have copyright protection,including the food industry.You cannot copyright a recipebecause it's a set of instructions, it's fact,and you cannot copyright the look and feelof even the most unique dish.Same with automobiles.It doesn't matter how wacky they look or how cool they look,you cannot copyright the sculptural design.It's a utilitarian article, that's why.Same with furniture,it's too utilitarian.Magic tricks, I think they're instructions, sort of like recipes:no copyright protection.Hairdos, no copyright protection.Open source software, these guys decidedthey didn't want copyright protection.They thought it'd be more innovative without it.It's really hard to get copyright for databases.Tattoo artists, they don't want it; it's not cool.They share their designs.Jokes, no copyright protection.Fireworks displays,the rules of games,the smell of perfume: no.And some of these industries may seemsort of marginal to you,but these are the gross salesfor low I.P. industries,industries with very little copyright protection,and there's the gross sales offilms and books.(Applause)It ain't pretty.

(Applause)

So you talk to people in the fashion industryand they're like, "Shhh!Don't tell anybodywe can actually steal from each other's designs.It's embarrassing."But you know what? It's revolutionary,and it's a model that a lot of other industries --like the ones we just saw with the really small bars --they might have to think about this.Because right now, those industries with a lot of copyright protectionare operating in an atmospherewhere it's as if they don't have any protection,and they don't know what to do.

When I found out that there are a whole bunch of industriesthat didn't have copyright protection,I thought, "What exactly is the underlying logic?I want a picture." And the lawyers do not provide a picture,so I made one.These are the two mainsort of binary oppositions within the logic of copyright law.It is more complex than this, but this will do.First: Is something an artistic object?Then it deserves protection.Is it a utilitarian object?Then no, it does not deserve protection.This is a difficult, unstable binary.

The other one is: Is it an idea?Is it something that needs tofreely circulate in a free society?No protection.Or is it a physically fixedexpression of an idea:something that somebody madeand they deserve to own it for a while and make money from it?The problem is that digital technologyhas completely subverted the logicof this physically fixed, expressionversus idea concept.Nowadays,we don't really recognize a bookas something that sits on our shelfor music as something that isa physical object that we can hold.It's a digital file.It is barely tethered to any sort ofphysical reality in our minds.And these things, because we can copy and transmit them so easily,actually circulate within our culturea lot more like ideasthan like physically instantiated objects.

Now, the conceptual issues are truly profoundwhen you talk about creativityand ownershipand, let me tell you, we don't want to leave this just to lawyers to figure out.They're smart.I'm with one. He's my boyfriend, he's okay.He's smart, he's smart.But you want an interdisciplinary team of peoplehashing this out,trying to figure out: What is the kind of ownership model,in a digital world,that's going to lead to the most innovation?And my suggestion is thatfashion might be a really good placeto start looking for a modelfor creative industries in the future.

If you want more information about this research project,please visit our website: it's ReadyToShare.org.And I really want to thank Veronica Jauriquifor making this very fashionable presentation.

Thank you so much. (Applause)

EL INGLÉS QUE TU CARRERA NECESITA, A TU RITMO

The following information is used for educational purposes only. EL INGLÉS QUE TU CARRERA NECESITA, A TU RITMO Reuniones, entrevistas, pre...